The Top 10 BNI Myths exposed!

May 27, 2010

The Top 10 BNI Myths exposed!

Julian Lewis is Managing Director of Berkshire based IT and telephony company Positive Computing Ltd in Reading. He has worked in the IT sector for over 20 years and has a wide breath of knowledge in both corporate and SME companies. Julian has been a member of Business Network International (BNI) for seven years and is also a BNI assistant Director.

Outside of his business interests Julian is Chairman of Newbury Rugby club which is a community rugby club in West Berkshire providing Rugby for All. A member of the Rugby Club’s management committee for eight years, Julian has also played for the club for 20 years from under 12 to 1st XV.

For BNI Julian is currently setting up two new groups one based in Reading and another in Thatcham. BNI sceptic Nigel Morgan invited Julian to contribute this guest post after he asserted many so-called truths about BNI were actually myths.

  1. You have to pass a referral every week


This is often quoted to me but in reality the truth is quite the opposite. Members of BNI work to a common philosophy of givers gain, if I give you business you will want to give me business in return. In effect this is not a direct cause and effect but what goes around does come around. Each week members are looking to pass genuine opportunities to do business where the person with the requirement is expecting a call. Members do not appreciate referrals that do not meet that criteria, it is not a numbers game.

BNI member are expect to make a contribution each week, because we don’t want to be part of a group where others are not contributing. A contribution could be a referral, but could also be bringing a visitor, or giving a testimonial. In addition BNI looks for business people that want to help other and the group as a whole.

  1. Only business start-ups join BNI

The facts show otherwise. 55% of BNI members have been in business more than 5 years 24% more than 2 years (less than 5) and only 10% are less than one year. BNI is for all businesses.

  1. BNI does not work

Members of BNI gave 659,066 referrals last year. Your share in this is guaranteed provided you embrace the system that is followed by BNI members worldwide. The BNI system has been developed over 25 years in 64 countries and is designed and proven to maximise the amount of business passed in the groups.

  1. You have to attend every meeting

BNI ask its members to make 3 commitments one is to be present at every meeting or to send a substitute. This policy ensures that your business is represented each week and this is one of the elements that makes the system work.

The key think in dispelling this myth is the substitute program which means you can send almost anybody in your place, this gives them the opportunity to represent their business as well as yours.

BNI members get organised in either attending or in send in a substitute, this approach maximises the business that is passed. Ultimately life happens and things happen at short notice meaning you miss a meeting with no sub, we understand that.

  1. BNI is just about getting more business for you

As well as getting business BNI has a comprehensive education program. As an example 86% of members agree that BNI has helped them with public speaking. BNI is not ashamed about the fact that we are all there to get more business, but we do it by giving first before we expect to receive and by building credibility.

  1. BNI is expensive

Cost is totally relative to everybody but some people believe that BNI is expensive. In our recent survey 81% of BNI members said that the organisation is value for money and 92% said that they would recommend BNI to family and friends. Asking people who have paid the BNI fees if BNI represents good value seems to me to be the best gauge of the value BNI delivers.

  1. BNI is a fashion and will not be around soon

BNI is 25 years old this year it is still growing and is the largest and most successful referral organisation in the world today.

  1. BNI groups are desperate for members

BNI members understand that being a member of BNI is a privilege and we realise that BNI is not right for everybody. If you want to join a group then you will go through an application process to see if the fit is right for both parties. BNI groups want to grow to 40+ members and we look constantly for likeminded local businesses to put in an application to join a local group.

  1. You have to join to get anything from BNI

BNI welcomes visitors at all meetings and we also run open networking meetings where non-members are welcome. 

  1. You only meet the same group of people each week.

BNI members can visit other BNI groups, we also hold local, regional, national and International members days. The people in the room are constantly inviting others to the group and of course they are meeting more and more people each week. BNI members understand that they are not selling to those in the room but to who they know.


Comments

Richard Charon said...

Nigel I know that you know that I know that BNI is not necessarily everyone's cup of tea. Horses for courses apply.

For some the formula works. It maximises the opportunities to network and gives a chance for everyone in the room to have a equal chance to put their USP forward in a limited time frame. I can also see why others might like a less focussed and less formal approach.

I'd like to take my hat off to you for allowing Julian Lewis, who obviously has embraced BNI and its modus operandi and no doubt finds it is cost effective and worthwhile in other ways, to correct some myths and put the BNI case, even if it does not necessarily accord with your own preference.

For the record I am in my 3rd year with the Jack O'Newbury Chapter of BNI and can see both sides of the argument. Certainly we have start ups but equally we have very well established business too.

Keep up the good work.

Richard Charon, 01/06/2010 19:12
www.newburysmilemakers.com
www.newburydentist.blogspot.com
www.twitter.com/richardcharon
www.linkedin.com/in/richardcharon
Mike Samuels said...

Since I've been recruiting for the FSB I have been listening to opinions on different networking groups. One of our top recruiters in the country achieves sign up targets by mainly focussing on BNI, so I feel I need to understand fully how it works.

So far I have only attended one BNI meeting, kindly facilitated by Richard Charon, so I am not in a position to make judgements, but certainly I have been exposed to the "myths".

Full marks must go to Nigel who openly declared his scepticism, for providing Julian with an opportunity to dispel these criticisms and negative comments.

As a recruiter and not a business I have yet to determine how this fits into the BNI mould but hopefully I will get the opportunity to investigate further.

Mike Samuels, 02/06/2010 17:35
www.medicalphotographer.co.uk
www.twitter.com/MikeSamuels68
www.linkedin.com/in/MikeSamuels68
Ken Norman said...

I must admit that I found BNI a bit of a struggle. As the group I was involved with grew (it was very much a numbers game as the group became fixated on growing to 43 strong) it became tedious listening to sixty-seconds X 40+ of the same stuff week-in week-out.

There was, I'm afraid, huge pressure to provide leads/bring visitors (see above) and often leads I provided just weren't appreciated - I evidently lived too far away from the chapter and some members just didn't want to travel to service the genuine leads I provided.

Generally the group was made up of a great bunch of folk - many of whom I stay in touch with and I still recommend it to certain trades and professions (the group was very property focussed - my business just didn't fit.)

I left (as several did before me) less than half way through the year - not a single piece of business resulted from the scant number of dubious leads handed over. If one of my customers terminated a contract before completion - I'd desperately want to know why. What were the circumstances? Was anything wrong? How could I make things right? What could I have done better?

I haven't heard a dicky-bird from BNI who seemed happy to take my dosh and just shrug their collective shoulders when I walked away. Doesn't make for creating the best advocates - does it?

So, the perception of BNI is invariably tainted by folk who've experienced similar levels of disinterest. Members who get the leads and the business are of course delighted and tremendous advocates but it should become more customer focussed. Perhaps if BNI better handled exiting members it wouldn't have to defend itself from the "myths" that have risen up around it. After all, Perception is Reality.

Ken Norman, 02/06/2010 18:22
www.newtricks.co.uk
www.newtrickstraining.wordpress.com
www.twitter.com/normanken
uk.linkedin.com/in/kennethnorman
Julian Lewis said...

Ken,

Thank you for your comments. I never feel the need to defend BNI, but I am so often asked the same questions some of which relate to what I have said above. I am not defensive of BNI, I say in my responses that BNI is not right for everybody and indeed not everybody is right for BNI.

I think in any organisation you will get people that fail to understand the program and try to distort it to suit them. You are right it is then up to BNI to ensure that the correct culture is maintained to avoid it becoming too casual or too authoritarian.

I speak above from my experience of BNI. I speak about the groups that I am involved with in Berkshire. (2 in Reading, Aldermaston and Thatcham)

My view on any networking group is, if you find a group that you like and that works (by your definition) then join it, embrace it and keep working the program. If it works for you and you enjoy it why would you not continue?

If you are ever passing I would love for you to visit one of these groups and take a fresh look at BNI.

Mike, I would love for you to visit one of my groups and see if it can help your business.

Julian Lewis, 02/06/2010 20:18
www.positivecomputing.com
www.positivecomputing.com/blog
Derek Rodgers said...

My own experience of BNI was in Yorkshire and was a few years ago. I did not attend for long myself but had colleagues who attended other Yorkshire chapters over a longer period.

I think it is fair to say that opinions were sharply divided. One camp (which included me) very quickly came to the conclusion that it was not for them. The other camp equally quickly became enthusiastic advocates. So it is clearly something which suits some people and not others.

For me, it was too formal, bordering on ritualistic! This may have been down to the way the particular chapter I attended was run. Like others who have commented on this article, I did find that there was great pressure to make referrals. A side effect of this was that those who continued to attend came back with 'referrals' which more often than not turned out to be wild goose chases. We would for example be given the name of someone who was said to want a shareholders agreement but when we contacted them, it became clear that this was something which they had perhaps vaguely mentioned in passing but had no intention of pursuing. As a solicitor, I was also uncomfortable with the requirement to stand up and make the referrals in front of the group as it was difficult to do this and maintain confidentiality.

The group which I attended did expect the same person to turn up every week, allowing only a couple of substitutions each year and made a big point of emphasising that members who failed to attend religiously would be expelled.

But, over the years I have met a lot of people, including former colleagues, who firmly believe that BNI provides a great forum for networking. Like any other networking forum, its success for you will depend mainly on what you put into it and whether its membership reflects your target audience. I guess the only way to find out if it will work for you is to give it a try.

Derek Rodgers, 02/06/2010 21:44
www.gardner-leader.co.uk
derekrodgersgl.wordpress.com
www.twitter.com/derekr_gl
Barbara Payne said...

I would like to comment on Julian’s BNI answers and I fully agree with every statement! I am going into my third year very soon at Basingstoke. And while it is not for everyone, there is definitely a place in the business arena for BNI.

BNI is not about going along and trying to grab every bit of business you possibly can and ‘sell, sell, sell’! Its really not. Its actually about helping other business people. The people I work with at BNI are genuine business people looking for business opportunities for me - the same as I am doing for them; if we all do that it becomes very easy to bring work to our colleagues.

The BNI training never gets mentioned much – but this is fantastic and will help all business owners to improve how they deliver their own message to new and existing customers. A way that is exciting, interesting and the things our customers want to hear! But in most cases we, as business owners, don’t actually know what will make our customers buy from us. BNI and the fellow members will help you enormously – we are your training team and sales team!

Barbara Payne

Barbara Payne, 07/06/2010 07:35
www.ddawebdesign.com
www.twitter.com/ddawebdesign
Dave Pincott said...

I have got to agree with Julian on BNI it doesnt suit everyone, however for those that it does your business can certainly reap the rewards.I have noted some comments about "it wasnt for me" or "nobody cared when I went".

Can I just say yes I am from a new business and have been a member for nearly a year. Times are tough however where else can you go to a meeting where - the chances are out of 20 plus professionals turning up week in week out - these same individuals have faced the same dilemas already.I can only take my hat off to those involved in helping me find my feet in the big wide world of business.

BNI has a simple set of rules and if followed in the manner laid out it can work for most companies.

Dave Pincott, 07/06/2010 15:01
www.fire-compliance-safety-reading.com
John Coupland said...

Great guest post from Julian.

For me, BNI's a 'no brainer'. Why would anyone not join the world's leading business referral organisation in which its MEMBERS produce such outstanding results?! Business passed last year in UK & Ireland was £230M - nearly 18% more than 2008....and in a recession!

Sure, BNI isn't for everyone - nor everyone for BNI!

What's undoubtedly important is the commitment and quality of its members. As we're all human, things of course may not go as well as planned but you CAN take action. For example, as with any other organisation, if the quality of the leadership or members is poor, there are several options: 1. Members vote to close the chapter (yes, contentious!) and relaunch another one with members who WILL add value and not simply expect business. 2. Change the leadership. 3. Try another chapter. 4. Coach the poor performers and, if all the options run out, tell them its not for them....(the list goes on)...

The BNI networking mechanism is, in my view, second to none. Why else has it got nearly 6000 chapters worldwide and been around for 25 years?

Competitors have tried to copy it - with poor results and many others try to knock it. (I'll leave it to you to wonder why!)

I left the corporate world nearly a year ago, after 25 years and have been amazed at the level of negativity and lack of enthusiasm amongst some SMEs / single traders. (Gosh and I thought the plc's were the downbeat ones!) What I love about BNI is the positivity - even at silly o'clock! - so much so that I'm now not only a member but a representative of this fantastic organisation and proud of it.

Here's to the next 25 years!

Good networking!

John :-)

BTW - If anyone's in SE London / NW Kent and wants to give it a try or another try, be my guest: http://www.londonbni.net/regional-directors.php?region=4&director=781 We also have a Members Day coming up on 25th June, London: http://www.bni.eu/events/bni-members-day-2010.php amongst others around the country. See you there?

John Coupland, 09/06/2010 15:18
www.bankonthepig.co.uk
networkerplus.wordpress.com
www.twitter.com/networkerplus
www.linkedin.com/in/networkerplus
Steve Boucher said...

Like any type of marketing, there is not a "one size fits all" solution - what may work well for one person may not work for someone else. The main thing is to recognise what works for you and what doesn't.

Although the BNI process can seem quite rigid, don't all we all follow a process of some sort in our businesses? Can you imagine what would happen if a surgeon didn't follow the process for carrying out a heart transplant?

Personally, the business I work for has benefitted massively from membership of BNI - in relation to the other advertising mediums we use, it represents excellent value for money. Yes, getting up at 5.00 am on a wet and windy freezing February morning is not always easy, but if success in life came easily we'd all be on a beach in the Bahamas knocking back cocktails toasting our achievements.

If BNI is not for you, move on and get over it - has everything you've tried in life always worked out the way you expected?

By the way I don't think I have ever seen anything from BNI that says you can't have fun at the Chapter meetings!

Steve Boucher, 21/06/2010 08:36
www.virtualcarsuperstore.co.uk
www.linkedin.com/profile?viewProfile=&key=52588926&locale=en_US&trk=tab_pro

Leave a Comment

Name (required)

Email (will not be published) (required)

Website

Blog

Twitter

LinkedIn

Submit Comment